![]() ![]() ![]() To influence the opinions of any responders 2) I hadn't tried it yet.Īll the responders to my original post made points which mirrored my own thoughts, which I didn't express any strong opinons about LilyPond in my OP because: 1) I didn't want Thanks to all those who responded to my query about LilyPond on and. I can do almost anything I have to with ABC, and if I found a use-case ABC didn't cover I suspect the chances are I'd end up needing Finale or Sibelius for some other reason (such as working with other people). Lilypond does have a MIDI output but by their own admission it is pretty basic as their focus is on engraving.Īt this point in time, I wouldn't personally (re)learn Lilypond unless I had very good reason. ![]() I can't really comment as it's something I've barely used as I can read a score faster than I can listen to it. These properties, like the properties associated with contexts, may be modified to change the operation of the engraver or the appearance of those elements in the printed score. For example, this paragraph from the help(!) text: "Each engraver processes the particular objects associated with its function, and maintains the properties that relate to that function. I can follow the basics but their comes a point where my brain gives in. I have sat down to learn Lilypond properly over the years and I must admit every time, so far, I have failed. It achieves this aim by making even the simple things verbose. Lilypond is designed with two things in mind - to produce excellent engraving - it certainly does - and to be able to do anything you could need it to do. However, it can take some figuring out and frankly at times knowing how a computer thinks can be a big help. It's also pretty good at doing things it *isn't* designed to do, by sheer dint of various people endlessly hacking at the various tools to make them do what they needed them to do. I can typeset pages and pages of tunes in minutes and be pretty confident that when I run it, the engraved output will be what I expected. I still think ABC (backed up by PDF or PNG images) is the best notation for posting tunes here (and for collecting tunes generally).ĭisclaimer: I have used ABC extensively for what will all too soon be two decades, so my views may be slightly coloured by exposure.ĪBC is very, very easy to use to do simple things that its creators intended. It can do more than ABC and isn't terribly hard to learn. That's purely a music editor, using its own XML based file format, but it's also free software, and it has been discussed at length on Melnet. ![]() If you want an alternative that's not quite so perfectionist as Lilypond, look at Musescore. I wouldn't say 'less functionality than ABC' - you can do just about anything with it but they are very different programs. You could try to compare EasyABC with Denemo or Fresocbaldi (music editors with Lilypond support)Īs with Musescore, and apparently to an even greater extent, you have finer control of the output and it is capable of typesetting features that can't easily or at all be done with ABC. The Lilypond program itself is just a command line tool that converts a Lilypond text file into one of several graphics formats (PDF, PS, SVG, PNG etc.), or displays it on the screen or prints it You have to create text files for input. You can't really talk about ease of use with Lilypond. * click the " open" icon to the right of the " Soundfont" textfield and choose FluidR3_GM.It is much more verbose than ABC, to the extent that I don't think you are expected to be able to simply type or read the code, but to use it with a dedicated editor ( these exist) or convert e.g. IMO, the FluidR3_GM.sf2 soundfont sounds better than default soundfont/SF2 file, TimGM6mb.sf2 (no offense to Tim Brechbill), so here's how to change the default soundfont in MuseScore: You might need to restart your computer after changing this setting, but you can try restarting pulseaudio first (after saving and closing MuseScore of course): so that you can listen to playback in MuseScore, but also listen to a YouTube video or play a video in VLC at the same time (i.e. Note: the I/O configuration is so that MuseScore doesn't "hog/hijack" the soundcard, i.e. In the I/O tab (applies to Ubuntu Linux): Initial Configuration (you only do this once)Ĭhoose " Color" for " Notesheet" (will give you a white background instead of light brown) MuseScore, IMO, seems the easiest and fastest way to create music notation, so I'll focus on this one and show you how to create a slash chord with a non-chord bass note, step by step, from scratch. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |